Oct 25 (Reuters) - Apple ( AAPL ) convinced a federal
jury on Friday that health monitoring tech company Masimo's ( MASI )
smartwatches infringe two of its design patents.
The jury, in Delaware, agreed with Apple ( AAPL ) that Masimo's ( MASI ) W1
and Freedom watches and chargers willfully violated Apple's ( AAPL )
patent rights in smartwatch designs, awarding the tech giant
$250 in damages. Apple's ( AAPL ) attorneys told the court the "ultimate
purpose" of its lawsuit was to win an injunction against sales
of Masimo's ( MASI ) smartwatches after an infringement ruling.
The jury also determined that Masimo's ( MASI ) watches did not
infringe Apple ( AAPL ) patents covering smartwatch inventions that the
tech giant had accused Masimo ( MASI ) of copying.
Masimo ( MASI ) said in a statement that the company appreciated the
jury's verdict "in favor of Masimo ( MASI ) and against Apple ( AAPL ) on nearly
all issues," and that the decision only applied to a
"discontinued module and charger."
"Apple ( AAPL ) primarily sought an injunction against Masimo's ( MASI )
current products, and the jury's verdict is a victory for Masimo ( MASI )
on that issue," Masimo ( MASI ) said.
Apple ( AAPL ) said in a statement that it was "glad the jury's
decision today will protect the innovations we advance on behalf
of our customers."
Irvine, California-based Masimo ( MASI ) accused Apple ( AAPL ) of hiring
away its employees and stealing its pulse oximetry technology
after discussing a potential collaboration. Masimo ( MASI ) convinced the
U.S. International Trade Commission last year to block imports
of Apple's ( AAPL ) Series 9 and Ultra 2 smartwatches after the
commission found that their technology for reading blood oxygen
levels infringed Masimo's ( MASI ) patents.
Apple ( AAPL ) has appealed the decision and resumed selling the
watches after removing the technology. The tech giant
countersued Masimo ( MASI ) for patent infringement in 2022, alleging
that Masimo ( MASI ) copied Apple Watch features to use in its
smartwatches.
Apple ( AAPL ) also accused Masimo ( MASI ) of using lawsuits at the ITC
and in California to "make way for Masimo's ( MASI ) own watch." Masimo ( MASI )
said Apple's ( AAPL ) patent lawsuit was "retaliatory" and "an attempt to
avoid the court in which the parties have been litigating their
dispute."