In an effort to avert a broader crisis, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) and other regulatory bodies took unprecedented measures, ensuring that depositors in SVB and Signature Bank, another failed institution, would have access to their funds, even those exceeding the $250,000 FDIC insurance limit.
The announcement of the First Citizens deal late Sunday appeared to achieve the desired outcome, as stock prices for regional banks like First Republic, PacWest Bancorp, and others deemed vulnerable to customer withdrawals rebounded. This development signifies a renewed sense of stability within the banking industry.
Aaron Klein, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and a former Treasury Department official, likened the financial system to a boat rocked by SVB's collapse, but expressed optimism that it is now stabilizing.
Klein emphasized the significance of the deal, but also highlighted the substantial losses incurred, particularly the potential $20 billion hit to the FDIC's deposit insurance fund. This amount, however, will not directly burden taxpayers but will be absorbed by an FDIC fund funded by banks.
The FDIC and First Citizens agreed to share potential losses or gains from the acquired loans, offering a safety net for both parties.
Klein posed the question of who should bear the burden of losses: senior depositors who may face reduced interest rates on their bank deposits or large depositors with balances exceeding $250,000 who could potentially lose a portion of their funds.
Todd Phillips, a fellow at the Roosevelt Institute and a former FDIC attorney, emphasized the importance of maintaining a sound and secure financial system, a sentiment echoed by officials from the Treasury Department and the Federal Reserve.
Phillips highlighted the extraordinary actions taken by regulators, including deposit guarantees and liquidity support programs, which have helped stabilize the overall banking system.
Agati pointed to rising interest rates, a result of the Federal Reserve's efforts to curb inflation, as a factor straining the system and potentially leading to reduced lending by banks, which could exert additional pressure on the economy.
She believes that the Fed's future actions will have a more significant impact on markets and the economy than the identification of the next bank facing potential stock declines.
The First Citizens-SVB deal, in Agati's view, does not significantly move the needle in terms of the overall market.
Customers of SVB will automatically become customers of First Citizens, with the former SVB branches reopening as First Citizens branches on Monday, as per the FDIC.
While New York Community Bank acquired a significant portion of Signature Bank in a $2.7 billion deal, the search for an SVB buyer took longer, culminating in the First Citizens acquisition.
First Citizens Bank, founded in 1898, saw a surge in its shares following the deal announcement, reflecting renewed confidence in the institution.