Donald Trump heads back to court after big Iowa win to face jury setting payout over E. Jean Carroll sex abuse and defamation claims
Former President Trump Faces Trial for Defamation Case Brought by E. Jean Carroll
Trial Details:
Following a significant victory in the Iowa caucus, former President Donald Trump is scheduled to appear in court on Tuesday to address a legal challenge brought forth by writer E. Jean Carroll. The trial aims to determine the extent of Trump's financial liability for denying allegations of sexual assault and accusing Carroll of fabricating her claims.
Jury selection commences on Tuesday morning at a federal court in Manhattan. Opening arguments are anticipated to take place in the afternoon, marking the commencement of what is essentially a second penalty phase in a legal battle that Carroll has already secured a victory in.
Previous Trial Outcome:
In May, a separate jury awarded Carroll $5 million after reaching a verdict that Trump sexually assaulted her in a department store dressing room during the spring of 1996. Subsequently, in 2022, Trump defamed Carroll by asserting that she fabricated the incident after she publicly disclosed it in her 2019 memoir. Notably, the jury did not find sufficient evidence to support Carroll's claim of rape.
Current Trial Focus:
The primary objective of the current trial is to determine the monetary compensation Trump owes Carroll for the defamatory remarks he made about her while serving as president. This aspect was not addressed in the previous trial.
Judge Lewis A. Kaplan ruled last year that the new jury is not required to revisit the issues of sexual abuse or the defamatory nature of Trump's statements, as these matters were conclusively determined in the first trial.
Trump's Expected Appearance:
Trump is anticipated to be present at the trial on Tuesday, although his plans for the remainder of the week remain uncertain due to the scheduling of his mother-in-law's funeral on Thursday. The trial is expected to span several days.
Trump has expressed his desire to testify, but strict limitations have been imposed on the scope of his testimony. He did not attend the previous trial last year, citing the advice of his lawyer.
Trial Restrictions:
Given the trial's exclusive focus on determining Trump's financial liability, Judge Kaplan has issued stern warnings to Trump and his legal team, prohibiting them from presenting arguments or making statements to the jury that have been previously uttered on the campaign trail or in other contexts. Specifically, they are barred from claiming that Carroll fabricated her story to promote her memoir.
Furthermore, Kaplan has imposed restrictions on discussing Carroll's past romantic relationships, sexual disposition, and prior sexual experiences. Additionally, any suggestion that Trump did not sexually abuse Carroll or that Carroll was motivated by political, financial, or mental health considerations is strictly prohibited.
The judge has also forbidden any arguments that contradict the court's ruling that "Mr. Trump, with actual malice, lied about sexually assaulting Ms. Carroll."
Restrictions Outside the Court:
It is important to note that these restrictions do not apply outside the presence of the jury. Consequently, Trump remains free to continue posting on social media about the aforementioned topics, as he has done frequently in recent days. However, each fresh denial carries the potential to escalate the damages he may be required to pay.
Trial Delay Request:
Judge Kaplan declined Trump's request to postpone the trial by a week. Nevertheless, he has granted Trump permission to testify as late as Monday, even if the trial is otherwise ready for closing arguments by Thursday.
Carroll's Testimony:
E. Jean Carroll, now 80 years old, intends to testify about the detrimental impact on her career and reputation resulting from Trump's public statements. She is seeking $10 million in compensatory damages and additional millions in punitive damages.
Trump's Stance:
Despite the adverse outcomes in court, Trump maintains his lead among Republicans in presidential primary polls. He plans to dedicate substantial time to defending himself in civil and criminal cases against him, viewing these legal battles as an integral part of his campaign.