April 16 (Reuters) - A former DraftKings executive on
Tuesday took to the witness stand to deny stealing the company's
trade secrets or soliciting its employees after he joined sports
betting rival Fanatics, saying he "operated with extreme
caution" in his exit.
But Michael Hermalyn's testimony before a federal judge in
Boston was quickly undercut by conflicting testimony by two
DraftKings employees who said he extended them multi-million
dollar pay packages if they followed him to Fanatics and helped
build out its nascent team catering to "VIP" clients.
Those employees, Andrew Larracey and Hayden Metz, said they
received offers from Hermalyn after calling him to learn about
his departure and while Hermalyn was in Los Angeles, where he
was staying at the home of Fanatics CEO Michael Rubin.
Those job offers included pay packages as high as $10
million for Metz, the men testified. Larracey said he quickly
applied and within days was interviewing with Fanatics
executives for a job he ultimately did not take.
"I had no reason to doubt that these were valid offers,"
Larracey said.
The hearing marked a crucial stage in a fast-moving lawsuit
filed in February by sports-betting giant DraftKings after
Hermalyn resigned on Feb. 1 ahead of the Super Bowl to become
the president of Fanatics' VIP program.
Fanatics, best known for selling sports jerseys and
merchandise, launched its sportsbook last year. DraftKings has
sought to block Hermalyn, who oversaw its relationships with its
largest customers, from working there.
U.S. District Judge Julia Kobick in issuing a temporary
restraining order on Feb. 8 declined to go so far as to block
Hermalyn's employment at Fanatics, opting instead to bar him
from soliciting clients and employees.
But she said she would reassess what restrictions were
needed in weighing a request for a preliminary injunction.
Tuesday's testimony, she said, would help her assess
"conflicting evidence" concerning whether Hermalyn
misappropriated confidential documents and breached a clause in
his contract barring him soliciting employees if he left.
Asked by his lawyer, Russell Beck, whether he had accessed
DraftKings' ( DKNG ) documents since resigning or disclosed information
to anyone at Fanatics, Hermalyn, who is now the president of
Fanatics' VIP division, said: "The answer is a hard no."
But DraftKings counsel Orin Snyder grilled Hermalyn
repeatedly about how he deleted large batches of files from a
work laptop in his final days of employment and transferred
documents, all of which Hermalyn said were personal.
Hermalyn acknowledged under questioning by Snyder that he
spoke with Larracey and Metz after taking the Fanatics job. But
he denied making any job offers to them, later telling Beck:
"Why would I do that on my first day and run and try to hire
these two people?" he testified.
"It just doesn't make any sense," he added.
The case is DraftKings Inc ( DKNG ) v. Hermalyn, U.S. District Court
for the District of Massachusetts, No. 1:24-cv-10299.
For DraftKings: Orin Snyder, Jason Schwartz, Harris Mufson
and Justin DiGennaro of Gibson Dunn & Crutcher and William Lee
and Drew Dulberg of Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale & Dorr
For Hermalyn: Russell Beck and Stephen Riden of Beck Reed
Riden
Read more:
DraftKings trade-secret case is 'character assassination,'
Fanatics exec says
Ex-DraftKings exec can work at Fanatics, can't solicit
clients during Super Bowl: judge
DraftKings sues former executive for taking secrets to
sports-betting rival