Feb 18 (Reuters) - Data analytics giant Equifax ( EFX )
must face a lawsuit by home mortgage lenders that accused it of
monopolizing the market for electronic income and employment
verification services, a federal judge in Philadelphia ruled on
Tuesday.
U.S. District Judge John Murphy rejected Equifax's ( EFX ) motion to
dismiss the case brought by Greystone Mortgage and First
Financial Lending, which alleged that the company used exclusive
long-term deals with worker data sources to squelch competition.
Employers, landlords and lenders use electronic verification
to review applicants' income and employment information. Equifax ( EFX )
receives verification information through its contracts with
payroll providers and major companies, the lawsuit said.
Greystone Mortgage and First Financial Lending said Equifax ( EFX )
is violating U.S. antitrust law by locking up data sources and
blocking rival verification services from receiving the same
work and income information.
Equifax ( EFX ) in a statement defended its platform and said it
will "continue to respond to this litigation through the
appropriate legal channels."
Lawyers for the plaintiffs did not immediately respond to a
request for comment.
The lawsuit was filed last May on behalf of a proposed class
of at least tens of thousands of purchasers of Equifax's ( EFX ) income
and employment services.
Greystone Mortgage and First Financial Lending said
Equifax's ( EFX ) alleged monopolization has meant fewer options and
higher prices for companies that rely on electronic
verification.
The lawsuit also accused Equifax ( EFX ) of using acquisitions to
maintain unfair dominance.
Murphy said Equifax's ( EFX ) industry deals ultimately "may be more
procompetitive than anticompetitive," but he said that dispute
is "for a different day."
The judge set a March 25 hearing to address the next phase
of the lawsuit.
The case is Greystone Mortgage Inc and First Financial
Lending LLC v. Equifax Workforce Solutions LLC and Equifax Inc ( EFX ),
U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania,
No. 2:24-cv-02260.
For plaintiffs: Katie Beran and Brian Ratner of Hausfeld;
Bruce Gerstein and David Rochelson of Garwin Gerstein & Fisher;
and Joshua Grabar of Grabar Law Office
For defendant: Leah Brannon and David Gelfand of Cleary
Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton, and Christopher Casey of Duane Morris
Read more:
Equifax ( EFX ) hit with antitrust class action over work
verification services